Dominic Fraser/Infinity
Commitment to our readers
The GOBankingRates editorial team is committed to providing you with unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methods to evaluate financial products and services – our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our review methodology for products and services.
20 years
Helping you become richer
trusted by
millions of readers
Japanese cars dominate reliability rankings for good reason. Toyota, Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Nissan and Mitsubishi vehicles often last hundreds of thousands of miles with basic maintenance. But mechanic Chris Pyle, who advises vehicle owners just answerWarns that not all Japanese brands deserve the same trust as retirees on fixed incomes.
Pyle said, “However, for the most part, these cars are very good and last a long time with few failures when they are treated and maintained well.”
The main thing is to know which specific brands and features create costly problems in the future.
Big Problem: CVT Transmission
Pyle’s harshest warning focuses on a technology that is spreading among Japanese brands: continuously variable transmissions.
“I would stay away from any vehicle that uses a CVT transmission,” he said. “Nissan makes the most of them in their cars and SUVs. They’re great until they’re not great. Then you get shocked with an outrageous repair bill, which usually means transmission replacement, not repair.”
CVT transmission promises better fuel economy by eliminating conventional gears. They operate smoothly for years, giving owners no warning that problems are coming. Then, they sometimes fail catastrophically.
Transmission replacement will be expensive; The repair bill could represent three to four months of Social Security payments for the average retiree. And unlike conventional transmissions, which can sometimes be rebuilt economically, failed CVTs usually require complete replacement.
Nissan uses CVTs in most of its lineup, which makes many Nissan vehicles problematic for retirees immediately.
Cars to Avoid: Infiniti Vehicles
Infiniti is Nissan’s luxury brand, and Pyle warns retirees to stay away from the entire lineup.
“I would stay away from most Infiniti vehicles; they are known to have electrical problems,” Pyle said. “They’re basically Nissan copycats with far more gadgets and appeal.”
The problem is not just of reliability. Infinity adds complications that retirees don’t need and can’t fix.
“You’re paying top price for features, not for superior drivelines and powertrains,” Pyle said. “There comes a time when too much is added to a vehicle. A retiree will not live in their car long enough to use, enjoy, or feel the need for all these features.”
For retirees, Infiniti represents the worst combination: luxury repair costs on vehicles that are no more reliable than their cheaper Nissan counterparts.
Cars to avoid: CVT-equipped Nissans
This range includes most modern Nissan sedans and SUVs. The Nissan Armada and Frontier appear on Pyle’s specific avoid list, although the CVT transmission warning is widespread across the brand.
“Nissan uses them the most in their cars and SUVs,” Pyle said. “They’re great until they’re not. Then you’re shocked with an outrageous repair bill, which usually means transmission replacement, not repair.”
Smart Shopping Strategy: Unpopular Models
Pyle offered retirees a money-saving strategy: target Japanese vehicles that don’t sell in large numbers.
“Below is a list of cars that don’t sell very well, which often means they’ll get a lower price or more incentive to buy them new,” he explained.
Their list includes:
- Toyota Tundra and 4Runner
- Honda Passport, Ridgeline and Odyssey
- Mazda Miata
These vehicles do not sell as well as competitors, but this does not reflect reliability problems. Lower sales volume means dealers offer better pricing to move inventory. For retirees, this creates opportunities to purchase reliable Japanese vehicles at a discount.
Best Bets: Toyota and Honda
“I would say that most Toyota and Honda brands tend to be great vehicles to own that tend to resell well and require little repair,” Pyle said.
Both brands also maintain extensive dealer and service networks, which makes sense for retirees who need accessible, affordable maintenance. Independent mechanics happily work on Toyotas and Hondas because parts are readily available and procedures are well documented.
The strong resale value cited by Pyle protects retirees’ investments. If you need to sell a 10 year old Toyota, its value is far better than most brands. This makes sense for people on fixed incomes who may need to draw down or access equity.