4pm Production / Shutterstock.com
Commitment to our readers
The GOBankingRates editorial team is committed to providing you with unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methods to evaluate financial products and services – our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our review methodology for products and services.
20 years
Helping you become richer
trusted by
millions of readers
As the American dream of living a financially stable life is slowly fading due to the rising cost of living and other economic pressures, the middle class also feels as if it is disappearing.
In some states, families at the bottom of the middle class are living paycheck to paycheck, while the average middle class tries to hold on to its position despite the growth of the top 1%.
To determine whether the middle class might actually disappear, I asked AI models ChatGPT and Perplexity if they thought the middle class would disappear, and if so, when.
The middle class is dividing and becoming hollow
Chatgpt said the middle class is unlikely to disappear entirely, although the version of it that many have grown up expecting is “dwindling away.” It believes that what is happening to the middle class is more a division or fracture than a disappearance.
Taking data from sources such as the Pew Research Center, it suggested that we now have a smaller, more secure upper middle class and a larger, more stressed “working middle” that earns good incomes but lacks a buffer. There is also a growing group that repeatedly falls out of the middle class, even though they technically qualify based on income.
AI Perplexity also does not commit to the idea of a disappearing middle class, but agrees that it is “changing shape.” Perplexity suggested that a more appropriate term is “hollowing out” the middle class, “where fewer families sit in the middle and more at both the low and high income levels.”
what did the middle class afford
ChatGPT explained that in the past, the equivalent of a comfortable middle-class life included being able to comfortably enjoy the following with money left over for savings:
- estimated salary
- employer health insurance
- affordable housing relative to income
- Pension or reliable retirement path
- One crisis at a time, not five at once
Confusedly it was also said that the middle class also used to be able to afford:
- A college education that wasn’t “wasted”
- A nice car (sometimes two)
- child care
- Minor holidays and other holidays
Why is the middle class suppressed?
Perplexity gave a more detailed explanation of why middle-class families feel cramped today, citing that the share of adults in middle-income families has fallen in recent decades and that the middle class controls “a smaller share of the national income” than in the 1970s.
ChatGPT suggested that “structural changes” such as globalization, automation, and loss of jobs in manufacturing and administration have also had a negative impact on the middle class. It divided the reasons as follows:
- Housing eats up 30% to 50% of take home pay.
- Health care costs are unpredictable.
- Retirement is self-funded and market dependent.
- Job security is thin.
- Economic “shocks” piled up (inflation + care + debt + housing).
Thus, ChatGPT suggested that people feel Poor even when they are not statistically poor.
When does it actually appear?
Chatgpt suggested that although the middle class may not disappear entirely, it is likely to continue to disintegrate. This broke it into two windows:
Already happening (now-2030)
Currently, Chatgpt said, middle-income families are relying more on loans and family support, with most of them only “one emergency away” from needing to borrow money. More traditional markers of success like home ownership and retirement preparation are falling out of favor later or disappearing altogether.
Acceleration Window (2030-2040)
Over the next few decades, the middle class may contain more people “with inheritance and family wealth” than people with higher wages. The circle of the middle class will also begin to widen, with two people with similar incomes living “vastly different lives” depending on their financial picture and location. This could make the middle class feel less like a broad group and more like a “conditional condition,” AI said.
The confusion is not so philosophical. It sees the middle class as remaining but weakened. Barring major policy changes (on wages, housing, taxes, education, health care), the middle class is likely to persist as a category, but with “less security, less political influence and a smaller share of total income than its earlier iterations,” AI said.
This could lead to “greater polarization and instability,” Perplexity said. With more people hovering just above or just below the traditional “middle class” line. This means they will own less assets, take on more debt and find themselves more vulnerable to economic shocks.
Geography will also matter, Perplexity said. While there are stable middle-skill jobs and better local policy, some regions and cities will maintain relatively strong middle classes, while others will see “sharp declines”.
The biggest myth to drop
Chatgpt insisted that the middle class would not disappear because capitalism needs consumers. However, it notes that some things may still change, such as the idea that hard work always creates security or that income alone defines class.
Perplexity suggested that barriers to entry into the middle class would be higher, especially if it remained tied to things like homeownership.
Becoming middle class in the future may require more active planning, maintenance, and even luck.