Commitment to our readers
The GOBankingRates editorial team is committed to providing you with unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methods to evaluate financial products and services – our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our review methodology for products and services.
20 years
Helping you become richer
trusted by
millions of readers
Retirement travel requires reliable transportation that holds value and doesn’t deplete savings through constant repairs. Some vehicles promise thrills or luxury but instead create costly headaches.
Chris Pyle, an auto expert just answerThe worst cars for retirees planning to travel and downsize were identified. Their recommendations focus on avoiding vehicles known for high maintenance costs, poor resale value, and frequent failures.
“As a retired individual or couple, there is no need to waste your retirement income or make high monthly payments on an expensive car. Look for a used car,” Pyle said.
Luxury models with rapid depreciation
lincoln nautilus
According to Pyle the Lincoln Nautilus suffers from engine noise and engine-related failures.
“Its value drops very rapidly,” he said.
cadillac lyrici
The Cadillac Lyriq is not known for parts failure, but it does tend to cause various problems.
“It’s full of electronics that are expensive to replace if they fail, and much of that electronics is hard to learn and understand, even for the younger generation,” Pyle said. The vehicle also experiences rapid depreciation like the Lincoln.
It is best to avoid off-road vehicles
jeep wrangler
The Jeep Wrangler may appeal to retirees who want to get off the beaten path and enjoy nature, but Pyle urged them to think twice.
“It’s plagued with deterioration of basically everything on the outside of the cab except the paint,” he said.
jeep grand cherokee
The Jeep Grand Cherokee has mostly the same problems but according to Pyle the list includes electronics failure.
“You’ll spend more time in the shop and less time enjoying retirement,” he said.
Compact cars with major flaws
volkswagen jetta
The Volkswagen Jetta has common brake problems and climate control concerns.
“Plus, it’s not easy to find shops to do work outside of VW,” Pyle said.
mitsubishi mirage
The Mitsubishi Mirage excels as an affordable basic car but fails for retired commuters.
“After 30 minutes in this car you’ll find your old joints will hate you,” Pyle said. This inconvenience makes it unsuitable for retirees planning road trips.
kia cadenza
The Kia Cadenza is priced semi-luxury but is on the low end of luxury according to Pyle.
He said, “It’s a reliable car though. You don’t get what you expected.”
electric vehicles with expensive repairs
Tesla and Rivian both made Pyle’s avoid list. Reasons also include the cost of ownership when the motor or battery warranty expires.
“The cost of the repair is very close to the value of the vehicle,” he said.
High collision repair costs and collision insurance can often equate to a car payment, according to Pyle.
new trucks cost more
Basically any new truck from Ford, Dodge, Chevy, Nissan or Toyota represents poor value.
“The prices range from light-duty to heavy-duty models,” Pyle said.
In the first five years of ownership, buyers lose approximately 35% to 55% of the vehicle’s value, in the $30,000 to $50,000 range.
“It’s better to buy used so the first owner takes the loss,” Pyle said.
Repeated repair nightmares
Jeep Renegade and Fiat 500 have the same chassis and are prone to repair problems.
“The cost of repairs is not as high as the frequency required,” Pyle said.
According to Pyle these cars spend more time sitting in shops waiting for repairs than running smoothly.
transmission failures
The Ford Fiesta and many Nissan cars and small SUVs have transmission problems.
“Dual clutch transaxles and CVT transaxles don’t keep up,” Pyle said.
Once they fail, the cost of repair becomes very expensive and most independent shops will not take on the work. “So they have to go to the dealer,” Pyle said.
Pyle’s advice for avoiding bad retirement vehicles focuses on three criteria: “Cars prone to failure, high maintenance costs, and very low resale value.”
Retirees planning a trip need vehicles that start reliably, handle long drives comfortably and retain value. The vehicles on Pyle’s list fail in a number of ways, making these costly mistakes for buyers on fixed incomes.
